Information for Reviewers
Reviewers like you form the core of the journal's peer-review process, and we provide you with an online system that is simple and easy to use.
Step One: Confirm Whether You Will Review
If an editor sends an email to you, requesting review of a submission:
- Click on the link in the email
- Follow the prompts to create an account, if you do not yet have one. Make sure to use the same email address that the editor used to contact you.
- Scan the webpage for the due date of the review. You may also download a PDF of the submission, if desired, before committing to review.
- Click on either "I will review it" or "I will not review it" to indicate whether you will return a review by the date requested.
Need help? If the link in the email is broken, or you are unable to retrieve the original email, go to ENTERDOMAIN.myaccount.cgi . Once you have logged in, click on the title of the submission, and follow the prompts above.
Step Two: Conduct Your Review
- Download the PDF from the webpage in Step One
- Write your review. Keep in mind the reviewer guidelines that you will receive via email from the editors. These guidelines help create comparable bases of analysis for each submission. If the editors have indicated that the reviews should be anonymous, take care not to include references that may reveal your identity, as editors may choose to share your review with the authors.
- Write your letter to the editor (optional). If you have additional comments that are "editors-only," prepare them in a separate file from your review
Note that you may receive reminders from the system to help you keep track of deadlines. If you will be unable to make your review deadline, please let the editors know by using the link in the email, and clicking on the sidebar link "Email editors."
Step Three: Submit Your Review
- Click on the link in the request email
- Click on the link "Submit Review"
- Complete the review form. Note you may upload your review and your cover letter in either Microsoft Word or RTF format, or simply cut and paste your comments into the fields provided.
- Click Submit to complete your review.
Thank you for reviewing for JOURNAL. The system will automatically notify the editors that you have completed your review.
For Further Assistance
For assistance with the content of your review, or if you would like to volunteer to review, contact LEAD EDITOR.
For assistance with your account or submitting your review, please contact Client Services at 510-665-1200, ext. 2, or email email@example.com.