•  
  •  
 

Abstract

This paper explores how nonprofit leaders can build more effective and more equitable court-ordered community service programs that support both organizational missions and the long-term success of justice-involved individuals. Drawing from literature in nonprofit management, volunteer administration, ethics, leadership, and criminal justice, this paper examines the barriers that often limit meaningful opportunities for court-ordered volunteers and the leadership competencies necessary to create stronger programs. To better understand current practices, I conducted semi-structured interviews with volunteer managers from Michigan nonprofit organizations about their experiences managing court-ordered volunteers, navigating organizational culture, and balancing inclusion with risk management concerns. Across interviews, several themes emerged including the importance of organizational culture, relationship-building, strategic planning, ethical leadership, and mentorship. While many organizations recognize the operational value of court-ordered volunteers, stigma and organizational hesitation often limit these volunteers to low-skill labor with little opportunity for growth or workforce development. This paper argues that nonprofit organizations are uniquely positioned to create more meaningful and restorative volunteer experiences that not only support organizational capacity, but also help returning neighbors build skills, belonging, and pathways toward long-term community reintegration.

Download

Share

COinS